About Us

Our History

Our policyholders own this company. This has proven a successful business model since 1873, and continues to this day.

We continually adapt to the needs of our customers.

Over the years, we have grown and merged with other smaller companies. Today, we have approximately 1,500 policyholders and had $631,683,114 of property insurance in force at the end of 2017.

We currently write business in Walworth, Rock, Dane, Jefferson, Green, Waukesha, Racine, and Kenosha Counties in southeastern Wisconsin.

Our mission is, “is to provide quality insurance service, at an equitable price, to the rural and small urban communities of Southeast Wisconsin.”

Employees
Chief Executive and President

Adam Reed

areed@sugarcreekmutual.com

Office Manager
Colette Frodl

cfrodl@sugarcreekmutual.com

Governance-Board of Directors
Chair of the Board

Bob Agnew

Vice Chair

Robert Janes

Secretary
Bruce Vander Veen

Treasurer

David Kyle
Directors
Don Schmaling
Jim Viney
Gene Lauderdale
Bob Johnson
Al McQuillen